Personally, I was very surprised by 2006's Silent Hill. I view it as one of those rare video game adaptations that really works as a stand-alone film. It had a creepy tone, decent acting, and some nice special effects. When I heard news of a sequel coming out, I was still looking forward to it because of the surprise the first film was to me.
Walking out of Silent Hill: Revelation, I felt cheated out of my money and my time. This didn't even feel like the first Silent Hill to me, it felt more of a ripoff of both the Resident Evil sequel films and all of the bad Saw sequels combined. It didn't even have the same creepy tone the first film had, one that differentiated horror films and video game adaptations for me.
I will get started with the acting in this film. This is possibly the worst ensemble cast I have seen this year! Everyone feels like they are reciting their lines rather than actually acting. Trust me, it was boring to watch! And the sad thing is, Sean Bean is even horrible in this film. Even in bad movies, the dude acts his best, but here, he is wasted by an awful director and an equally horrible script.
The script is pure garbage as well. There is awful dialogue throughout, mostly discussing character's courses of action and what they plan to do in the next scene. Being a film student, I was taught to never have characters speak about intents or courses of action, so this film fails in its writing. The film also relies on constant and obvious plot twists throughout. Whenever a character is introduced, you have a feeling that the character is up to no good. Surprise! It turns out that character is up to no good. The film fails at actually tricking its audience as well.
Technically, the film is bad too. The visual effects are awful here, worse than the first film released in 2006. The monsters look stupid here rather than horrifying and creepy. And Silent Hill itself doesn't even seem as creepy as the first film was. The only benefits I had from watching this film were listening to the awful but easily laughable dialogue and that the 3D actually wasn't that bad. But do these benefits really change my perception of this film as a whole?
The answer to that question is no. Silent Hill: Revelation 3D is truly a mess. This will go down as one of the worst sequels I have ever seen and easily one of the worst video game adaptations of all time. It's a waste of a sequel to a film I consider one of the stronger video game adaptations. Easily one of the worst of 2012, it's a must-avoid to fans of the first film and the video games.
Rating: 1 out of 10- Pure Garbage, barely any or no redeeming qualities to it at all.